Derek Simonds Creator, Executive Producer Jessica Biel Cora Tannetti Actor, Executive Producer Christopher Abbott Mason Tannetti Actor Bill Pullman Detective Harry Ambrose Actor Dohn Norwood Dan Leroy Actor Abby Miller Caitlin Sullivan Voice C.J. Wilson William Guest Star Nadia Alexander Adult Phoebe Guest Star Enid Graham Elizabeth Lacey Guest Star Danielle Burgess Maddie Guest Star Jacob Pitts J.D. Guest Star Adam LeFevre Police Chief Guest Star Robert Funaro Ron Tannetti Guest Star Joanna P. Adler Captain Anne Farmer Guest Star Kathryn Erbe Fay Ambrose Guest Star Patti D'Arbanville Lorna Tannetti Guest Star Cherien Dabis Director Charlie Gogolak Executive Producer Michelle Purple Executive Producer