Russell Johnson Pete Corrigan Actor Paul Hartman Police Sergeant Actor Bartlett Robinson William Actor John Lasell Jonathan Wellington Actor Nora Marlowe Chambermaid Actor Jimmy Lydon Patrolman Actor Raymond Bailey Millard Actor Raymond Greenleaf Jackson Actor John Eldredge Whittaker Actor James Gavin Policeman Actor Jean Inness Mrs. Landers Actor Lew Brown Lieutenant Actor Carol Eve Rossen Lieutenant's Girl Actor Pat O'Malley Attendant Actor Rod Serling Host, Writer Buck Houghton Producer David Orrick McDearmon Director