Padma Lakshmi Host Tom Colicchio Judge Gail Simmons Judge Graham Elliot Judge Silvia Barban Contestant Emily Hahn Contestant Jamie Lynch Contestant Annie Pettry Contestant Sylva Senat Contestant Gerald Sombright Contestant BJ Smith Contestant Jim Smith Contestant Sam Talbot Contestant Casey Thompson Contestant Amanda Baumgarten Contestant Brooke Williamson Contestant Sheldon Simeon Contestant John Tesar Contestant Shirley Chung Contestant Katsuji Tanabe Contestant Dan Cutforth Executive Producer Jane Lipsitz Executive Producer