Gail Simmons Host Johnny Iuzzini Judge Hubert Keller Judge Dannielle Kyrillos Judge Sherry Yard Guest Zac Young Contestant Danielle Keene Contestant Morgan Wilson Contestant Yigit Pura Contestant Erika Davis Contestant Heather Hurlbert Contestant Heather Chittum Contestant Eric Wolitzky Contestant Casey Kriley Executive Producer Fred Pichel Executive Producer