Matt Bomer Neal Caffrey Actor Tim DeKay Peter Burke Actor Tiffani Thiessen Elizabeth Burke Actor Willie Garson Mozzie Actor Marsha Thomason Diana Berrigan Actor Sharif Atkins Clinton Jones Actor James Rebhorn Reese Hughes Guest Star Paul Blackthorne Julian Larssen Guest Star Ato Essandoh Frederick Bilal Guest Star Jayce Bartok Devlin Guest Star Kevin Kilner Agent Roe Guest Star Hilarie Burton Sara Ellis Guest Star Phil E. Eichinger Bartender Guest Star Tracy Jai Edwards Woman Forger Guest Star Jeff Greene Jed Bowers Guest Star Gian-Murray Gianino Pedro Guest Star Joel Van Liew Businessman Guest Star Lisa Velten Smith Captain Guest Star Jeff Eastin Executive Producer