A Nous la Liberté (Liberty for Us)

Critics Consensus

No consensus yet.



Total Count: 17


Audience Score

User Ratings: 2,414
User image

A Nous la Liberté (Liberty for Us) Photos

Movie Info

À Nous la Liberté is an early talkie from French filmmaker René Clair. Louis (Raymond Cordy) and Emile (Henri Marchand) are a pair of convicts whose lives take decidely different paths after prison. Emile works his way up the ladder of capitalism, becoming a phonograph factory boss, a job that finds him overseeing a bleak outfit of automatous drones. Louis, on the other hand, lives the life of a poverty-stricken vagabond. Despite their contrasting lots, the pair meet up again later in life. À Nous la Liberté is perhaps best remembered for being the main inspiration for Charlie Chaplin's 1936 classic Modern Times. ~ Matthew Tobey, Rovi


Critic Reviews for A Nous la Liberté (Liberty for Us)

All Critics (17) | Top Critics (3) | Fresh (17)

Audience Reviews for A Nous la Liberté (Liberty for Us)

  • Sep 01, 2011
    Going beyond the usual Clair vs. Chaplin debate, A Nous la Liberté is a superior film in terms of satire and criticism. The neoliberal motors of the "organization and progress" motto carry the idea that "work is liberty"; not only that is a lie, but also an idea carried out by modern industrialization enterprises and factories. Addressing such hard topics in a comedic, slapstick way is one of the most unusual moves I've ever seen in cinema (Chaplin may have thought the same). Hence, the ending is a hilarious irony: the substitution of labor by machines and capital caused the exact opposite result. That's the motto of exploitation: "either you accept my preposterous wage or you can eat dust". 99/100
    Edgar C Super Reviewer
  • Sep 03, 2010
    A great movie with a great message.
    Aj V Super Reviewer
  • Jul 04, 2007
    A very fun little gem. It's very clasically cute, with all its slapstick and its musicalization. The story is a critical comparison of a prison and a factory! Chaplin drew inspiration from it for Modern Times. It isn't a must see but it's one of those movies that can be appreciated for their simplicity, their wit and their charm.
    Elvira B Super Reviewer

A Nous la Liberté (Liberty for Us) Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features