Anatomy of a Murder (1959) - Rotten Tomatoes

Anatomy of a Murder (1959)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: One of cinema's greatest courtroom dramas, Anatomy of a Murder is tense, thought-provoking, and brilliantly acted, with great performances from James Stewart and George C. Scott.

Anatomy of a Murder Videos

Anatomy of a Murder Photos

Movie Info

Based on the best-selling novel by Robert Traver (the pseudonym for Michigan Supreme Court justice John D. Voelker), Anatomy of a Murder stars James Stewart as seat-of-the-pants Michigan lawyer Paul Biegler. Through the intervention of his alcoholic mentor, Parnell McCarthy (Arthur O'Connell), Biegler accepts the case of one Lt. Manion (Ben Gazzara), an unlovable lout who has murdered a local bar owner. Manion admits that he committed the crime, citing as his motive the victim's rape of the alluring Mrs. Manion (Lee Remick). Faced with the formidable opposition of big-city prosecutor Claude Dancer (George C. Scott), Biegler hopes to win freedom for his client by using as his defense the argument of "irresistible impulse." Also featured in the cast is Eve Arden as Biegler's sardonic secretary, Katherine Grant as the woman who inherits the dead man's business, and Joseph N. Welch -- who in real life was the defense attorney in the Army-McCarthy hearings -- as the ever-patient judge. The progressive-jazz musical score is provided by Duke Ellington, who also appears in a brief scene. Producer/director Otto Preminger once more pushed the envelope in Anatomy of a Murder by utilizing technical terminology referring to sexual penetration, which up until 1959 was a cinematic no-no. Contrary to popular belief, Preminger was not merely being faithful to the novel; most of the banter about "panties" and "semen," not to mention the 11-hour courtroom revelation, was invented for the film. Anatomy of a Murder was filmed on location in Michigan's Upper Peninsula.
Rating:
G
Genre:
Classics , Drama , Mystery & Suspense
Directed By:
Written By:
In Theaters:
 wide
On DVD:
Runtime:
Studio:
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment

Watch it now

Cast

James Stewart
as Paul Biegler
Lee Remick
as Laura Manion
Ben Gazzara
as Lt. Frederick Manion
Arthur O'Connell
as Parnell McCarthy
Eve Arden
as Maida
Kathryn Grant
as Mary Pilant
Joseph N. Welch
as Judge Weaver
Douglas Brooks West
as Mitch Lodwick
George C. Scott
as Claude Dancer
Murray Hamilton
as Alphonse Paquette
Orson Bean
as Dr. Smith
Alexander Campbell
as Dr. Harcourt
Joseph Kearns
as Mr. Burke
Russ Brown
as Mr. Lemon
Howard McNear
as Dr. Dompierre
Ned Wever
as Dr. Raschid
Jimmy Conlin
as Madigan
Ken Lynch
as Sgt. Durgo
Don Ross
as Duane Miller
Lloyd Le Vasseur
as Court Clerk
Royal Beal
as Sheriff Battisfore
James Waters
as Army Sergeant
Duke Ellington
as Pie-eye
Irving Kupcinet
as Distinguished Gentleman
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Anatomy of a Murder

Critic Reviews for Anatomy of a Murder

All Critics (42) | Top Critics (5)

At 160 minutes, Anatomy is longer than the subject warrants, but the pace seldom slackens -- thanks to the competence of Director Otto Preminger.

Full Review… | April 24, 2009
TIME Magazine
Top Critic

Preminger purposely creates situations that flicker with uncertainty, that may be evaluated in different ways. Motives are mixed and dubious, and, therefore, sustain interest.

Full Review… | October 23, 2007
Variety
Top Critic

As an entertaining look at legal process, this is spellbinding all the way, infused by an ambiguity about human personality and motivation that is Preminger's trademark, and the location shooting is superb.

Full Review… | October 23, 2007
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

Coolly absorbing, nonchalantly cynical.

Full Review… | June 24, 2006
Time Out
Top Critic

It is the best courtroom melodrama this old judge has ever seen.

Full Review… | May 20, 2003
New York Times
Top Critic

Otto Preminger's cynical view of the judicial system is curiously contemporary and still serves as a blueprint for numerous TV 'tec shows.

Full Review… | November 6, 2013
Total Film

Audience Reviews for Anatomy of a Murder

½

With a fantastic cinematography and superb direction, this superlative courtroom procedural unfolds in an unhurried fashion, daring to make outspoken use of sexual terminology (something unthinkable at the time it was made) and presenting a brilliantly complex script centered on a fiery, breathtaking rhetorical combat of the highest quality.

Carlos Magalhães
Carlos Magalhães

Super Reviewer

Though this adaptation of a best-selling novel may not seem like it now, it was quite a groundbreaking big deal when it came out. The story, a stirring courtroom drama, follows an alcoholic, fly-by-the-seat-of-his-pants small town lawyer (Jimmy Stewart going against type), defending a man who openly admits to murdering someone, but only because said individual raped his wife, who, admittedly, is kinda a floozy. Stewart's character understandably has a lot going against him, and that's not including the fact that the prosecution is made up of some slick, hard-cased big city guys led by George C. Scott. Like I said, this was a big deal at the time, mostly due to the subject matter, and how director Otto Preminger dealt with it. He did a great job of dealing with stuff that, until then, hadn't really been covered in cinema. Yeah, like I said, some of the impact has diminished, but that doesn't take away from the fact that it's still a powerful and engaging piece of work. The opening titles by Saul Bass are the stuff of legend, the score by Duke Ellington is a jazz classic, and the performances, as one may expect, are quite good. I mean, there's Stewart, Scott, and Lee Remick as the floozy wife, all of whom are quite great. Oh yeah, and Ben Gazzara as the man on trial. This one kinda set the standard for a lot of courtroom dramas to come, and it is quite realistic, accurate, and does a fine job of trying to show things in a pretty down to Earth way. So yeah, I dig the film a lot, but I'll admit that the running time could be cut down a bit, and some of the pacing trimmed as well. It's quite engaging, but once in a while it gets slightly boring, but not enough to really derail things. While I don't feel like a lot of people do, I still think this is a fine film worth seeing, even if I don't regard it as a masterpiece like a lot of others do.

Chris Weber
Chris Weber

Super Reviewer

Amazing dialog and performances. There's a reason you've seen this ripped off 100000000 times. The legal procedural drama starts here. Plus, a Duke Ellington score!

Ken Stachnik
Ken Stachnik

Super Reviewer

Anatomy of a Murder Quotes

Discussion Forum

Discuss Anatomy of a Murder on our Movie forum!

News & Features