Ken Marino Director Nina Dobrev Elizabeth Actor Vanessa Hudgens Tara Actor Adam Pally Dax Actor Eva Longoria Grace Actor Rob Corddry Kurt Actor Tone Bell Jimmy Actor Jon Bass Garrett Actor Michael Cassidy Dr. Mike Actor Finn Wolfhard Tyler Actor Ron Cephas Jones Walter Actor Thomas Lennon Greg Actor Tig Notaro Danielle Actor Lauren Lapkus Daisy Actor Jessica St. Clair Ruth Actor Ryan Hansen Peter Actor Tony Cavalero Stanley Actor Jessica Lowe Amy Actor Mo Gaffney Mayor Velez Actor Jasmine Cephas Jones Lola Actor Elizabeth Phoenix Caro Amelia Actor Casey Deidrick Jude Actor Phoebe Neidhardt Alexa Actor John Gemberling Ernie Actor Arielle Vandenberg Kristen Actor Toks Olagundoye Nina Actor David Wain Wacky Wayne Actor Matt Cordova Ben Actor Elissa Matsueda Screenwriter Erica Oyama Screenwriter Mickey Liddell Producer Pete Shilaimon Producer Jennifer Monroe Producer Alison Semenza King Executive Producer Nicole Stojkovich Executive Producer Scott Holroyd Executive Producer Michael Glassman Executive Producer Frank Barrera Cinematographer Brian Scofield Film Editing Craig Wedren Original Music Matt Novack Original Music Marcia Hinds Production Design Michael Allen Glover Art Director Kathy Orlando Set Decoration Molly Grundman Costume Design Susie Farris Casting