John Asher Director, Executive Producer Tom Everett Scott Nick Pearson Actor Tituss Burgess The Amazing Fabular Actor Julian Feder Mason Actor Rachel Boston Sydney Bartlett Actor Rhea Seehorn Kelly Actor Julie Ann Emery Joanna Actor Beth Riesgraf Schyler Actor Arden Myrin Janice Bodicker Actor Bryan Batt Reverend McGooley Actor Joyce Bulifant Betty Bartlett Actor Ray Abruzzo Walter Actor Andrew Bowen Richard Actor Michael McHale Deejay Actor Marisa Tomei Christine Hurley Actor Chris Levine Winny, Freddy Actor Nathan Arenas Frank Actor Frank Dietz Screenwriter Todd Traina Screenwriter, Producer John Landis Executive Producer Rachel McHale Producer Blake T. Evans Cinematographer Mary Jo Slater Casting Alan E. Muraoka Production Design Gerald Lehtola Art Director Inanna Bantu Costume Design