Max Joseph Director, Screenwriter Zac Efron Cole Carter Actor Wes Bentley James Actor Emily Ratajkowski Sophie Actor Jonny Weston Mason Actor Shiloh Fernandez Ollie Actor Alex Shaffer Squirrel Actor Jon Bernthal Paige Actor Alicia Coppola Mrs. Romero Actor Wiley Pickett Carl Actor Jon Abrahams Nicky Actor Brittany Furlan Sara Actor Vanessa Lengies Mel Actor Rebecca Forsythe Clarissa Actor Joey Rudman Joey Actor Kelsey Formost Rebecca Actor Scarlett Benchley Mindy Actor Devon Barnes Heather Actor Rob Silverman Valley Hater Actor Timothy Granaderos Preppy Guy No. 1 Actor Raleigh Adams Preppy Guy No. 2 Actor Kerry Stein Rabbi Actor Meaghan Oppenheimer Screenwriter Richard Silverman Executive Producer Olivier Courson Executive Producer Ron Halpern Executive Producer Nathan Kelly Executive Producer Tim Bevan Producer Eric Fellner Producer Liza Chasin Producer Brett Pawlak Cinematographer Terel Gibson Film Editing David Diliberto Film Editing Maya Sigel Production Design Shannon Kemp Art Director Siobhan O'Brien Set Decoration Christie Wittenborn Costume Design Courtney Bright Casting Nicole Daniels Casting