Christine Connor Creator, Executive Producer Aurora Heimbach Kitty Genovese Actor Clinton Faulkner Winston Moseley Actor Athena Masci Sophie Farrar Actor Michael Lester Karl Ross Actor Caitlin Mehner Mary Ann Zielonko Actor Christopher Spurrier Detective Carroll Actor Jasson Finney Detective Sang Actor Craig Thomas Rivela Detective John Tartaglia Actor Brandon Despain Joseph Fink Actor Phil Simone Robert Mozer Actor Julia Johnston Andre Picq Actor Jim Dailakis Samuel Koshkin Actor Marlene Eckhardt Mrs. Mozer Actor Maureen Lahey Greta Schwartz Actor Tami McCarthy Irene Frost Actor Tim Pappalardo Edward Feisler Actor A.C. Roe Martin Gansberg Actor Cliff Staebler Edward Bieniewicz Actor Alyssa Pinsker Anna Bieniewicz Actor James Aiello Jack Timmins Actor Paul Moon A.M. Rosenthal Actor Andrea Schirmer Marjorie Koshkin Actor Andy Talen Victor Horan Actor Catherine Oberg Narrator Robyn Babina Narrator Lee Beckett Executive Producer Thomas Cutler Executive Producer Cruz Angeles Writer