Kathy Bates Agnes Mary Winstead, Thomasin 'The Butcher' White Actor Sarah Paulson Audrey Tindall, Lana Winters, Shelby Miller Actor Cuba Gooding Jr. Dominic Banks, Matt Miller Actor Lily Rabe Shelby Miller Actor André Holland Matt Miller Actor Denis O'Hare William van Henderson, Dr. Elias Cunningham Actor Wes Bentley Dylan, Ambrose White Actor Evan Peters Rory Monahan, Edward Philippe Mott Actor Cheyenne Jackson Sidney Aaron James Actor Angela Bassett Monet Tumusiime, Lee Harris Actor Finn Wittrock Jether Polk Guest Star Adina Porter Lee Harris Guest Star Robin Weigert Mama Polk Guest Star Chelsea Alden Alissa Guest Star Susan Berger Real Butcher Guest Star Crystal Liu Writer Elodie Keene Director