Forest Whitaker Special Agent Sam Cooper Actor Janeane Garofalo Beth Griffith Actor Michael Kelly John "Prophet" Sims Actor Beau Garrett Gina LaSalle Actor Matt Ryan Mick Rawson Actor Kirsten Vangsness Penelope Garcia Actor Richard Schiff Richard Schiff Guest Star Gary Basaraba William Meeks Guest Star John Posey Principal Spurell Guest Star Ron Perkins Reverend Sands Guest Star David Trice Jim Guest Star Sam Ayers Det. Sykes Guest Star Chris Sheffield Shawn Meeks Guest Star Aaron Refvem Paul Meeks Guest Star Lenora May Rose Hayward Guest Star Rico McClinton Cop Guest Star Michelle N. Carter ER Nurse Guest Star Jack Axelrod Janitor Guest Star Carr Thompson David Henry Guest Star Chris Mundy Executive Producer, Writer Edward Allen Bernero Executive Producer Mark Gordon Executive Producer Deborah Spera Executive Producer Andrew Bernstein Director Ian Goldberg Writer