George Rexstrew Edwin Payne Actor Jayden Revri Charles Rowland Actor Kassius Nelson Crystal Palace Actor Yuyu Kitamura Niko Actor Jenn Lyon Esther Actor Briana Cuoco Jenny the Butcher Actor Ruth Connell The Night Nurse Actor Lukas Gage Cat King Actor David Iacono David the Demon Actor Steve Yockey Executive Producer, Writer Beth Schwartz Executive Producer Jeremy Carver Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Leigh London Redman Executive Producer Neil Gaiman Executive Producer Lee Toland Krieger Executive Producer, Director