Shanola Hampton Gabi Mosely Actor Mark-Paul Gosselaar Sir Actor Kelli Williams Margaret Reed Actor Karan Oberoi Dhan Rana Actor Gabrielle Walsh Lacey Quinn Actor Brett Dalton Mark Trent Actor Arlen Escarpeta Zeke Wallace Actor Danielle Savre Lena Matthews Guest Star Parker Queenan Jamie Reed Guest Star Scott Johnson Darryl Reed, Chester Roberts Guest Star, Guest Star Callie McClincy Taylor Reed Guest Star Sarah Borne Rachel Reed Guest Star Vince Foster FBI Agent Millen Guest Star A.J. Troup Daniel Schenkor Guest Star Paul Schackman Rabbi Steven Mendel Guest Star Elijah Wood Elmore Roberts Guest Star Peter Jacobson Jacob Lieb Guest Star Brittany Wilkerson Molly Lieb Guest Star Jacob Wilhelmi Zev Braunstein Guest Star Bethany Geaber Tierza Braunstein Guest Star Ava Mize Eden Braunstein Guest Star Brandon Belieu Burton Kester Guest Star Nkechi Okoro Carroll Executive Producer Sonay Hoffman Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Leigh London Redman Executive Producer Lindsay Dunn Executive Producer DeMane Davis Director Michael G. Peterson Writer Jeremy Powell Writer