Casey Lane Self Brendan Collins Self Brooke Williamson Self Chris Nirschel Self Brian Jong-Han Kho Contestant Amanda Jean Contestant Harrison Bader Contestant Suki Secka Contestant Will Andersen Contestant Jake Weber Contestant Lorena Bolanos Contestant Gillian Espinosa Contestant Mike Duffy Writer, Executive Producer Ted Iredell Executive Producer Rob Lobl Executive Producer Anthony Sylvester Producer