Matt Dallas Kyle Actor Marguerite MacIntyre Nicole Trager Actor Bruce Thomas Stephen Trager Actor April Matson Lori Trager Actor Jean-Luc Bilodeau Josh Trager Actor Chris Olivero Declan McDunaugh Actor Kirsten Zien Amanda Bloom Actor Jaimie Alexander Jessi XX Actor Ally Sheedy Guest Star Chelan Simmons Guest Star Magda Apanowicz Guest Star Josh Zuckerman Guest Star Teryl Rothery Guest Star Hal Ozsan Guest Star Adam Lolacher Guest Star Chris Grismer Director Eric Tuchman Writer