Arielle Vandenberg Host Matthew Hoffman Narrator Olivia Kaiser Contestant Kyra Lizama Contestant Trina Njoroge Contestant Cashay Proudfoot Contestant Shannon St. Claire Contestant Korey Gandy Contestant Josh Goldstein Contestant Jeremy Hershberg Contestant Melvin "Cinco" Holland Jr. Contestant Christian Longnecker Contestant Will Moncada Contestant Javonny Vega Contestant Leslie Golden Contestant Isabel Johnson Contestant Raúl Frías Contestant Genevieve Shawcross Contestant Kay Taylor Contestant Florence "Flo" Mueller Contestant Andrew Philips Contestant Tony "Ballo" Caraballo Contestant Gabe Sadowsky Contestant Charlie Lynch Contestant David George Executive Producer Adam Sher Executive Producer David Eilenberg Executive Producer