James Wolk Joe Kimbreau Actor Charlie Barnett Eric Payne Actor Elizabeth Lail Jenny Banks Actor Natalie Martinez Amy Kindelan Actor Gabrielle Byndloss Mallory Guest Star Joe Carroll Ray Jaffin Guest Star Curtis Edward Jackson Wayne Coleman Guest Star Charline St. Charles District Attorney Guest Star Russel Friend Executive Producer, Writer Garrett Lerner Executive Producer, Writer Matt Reeves Executive Producer Adam Kassan Executive Producer Rafi Crohn Executive Producer Howard Klein Executive Producer Adam Davidson Executive Producer Chris Koch Director