Sam Witwer Aidan Actor Sam Huntington Josh Actor Meaghan Rath Sally Actor Kristen Hager Nora Sergeant Guest Star Natalie Brown Julia Guest Star Robert Naylor Stevie Atkins Guest Star Kyle Switzer Jesse Guest Star Olunike Adeliyi Cecilia Guest Star Dichen Lachman Suren Guest Star Jonah Carson Phil Guest Star Thomas Vallières Drunk College Boy 1 Guest Star Nastassia Markiewicz Adorable Co-Ed , Hot Girl Guest Star Kyle Gatehouse Atlee Guest Star Jeremy Carver Executive Producer Anna Fricke Executive Producer Michael Prupas Executive Producer Adam Kane Director