Justin Theroux Kevin Garvey Actor Amy Brenneman Laurie Garvey Actor Christopher Eccleston Matt Jamison Actor Liv Tyler Meg Abbott Actor Margaret Qualley Jill Garvey Actor Chris Zylka Tom Garvey Actor Carrie Coon Nora Durst Actor Ann Dowd Patti Levin Actor Janel Moloney Mary Jamison Actor Regina King Erika Murphy Actor Kevin Carroll John Murphy Actor Jovan Adepo Michael Murphy Actor Jasmin Savoy Brown Evie Murphy Guest Star Darius McCrary Isaac Rayney Guest Star Steven Williams Virgil Guest Star Dominic Burgess Dr. Goodheart Guest Star Mark Linn-Baker Himself Guest Star Aaron D. Alexander Ranger Guest Star Brittany Angley Savior Guest Star Michael Basil Park Ranger Guest Star Violett Beane Taylor Guest Star David Blackwell Tobacco Vendor Guest Star Amory Casto Barefoot Woman Guest Star Timothy Eric Reverend Massey Guest Star Denton Blane Everett T.J. Guest Star Ryan Hamilton Barefoot Man Guest Star Katy Harris Violet Guest Star Cody Haynes Jerry Guest Star Nicky Mondellini German Woman Guest Star Turk Pipkin Pillar Man Guest Star Julitta Pourciau Heavy Set Woman Guest Star Carlos Sepulveda Debbin Guest Star Ben Taylor Fat German Man Guest Star Sara Tomko The Woman Guest Star Lawrence Varnado Cedric Guest Star Curtis Wayne Mounted Ranger Guest Star Cyndi Williams Waitress Guest Star Erica Francoise Abraham Indian Visitor Guest Star Brandi Jamille Brown Diner Patron Guest Star Rebecca Chulew Churchgoer Guest Star Bonnie Ann Coronado Cave Woman Guest Star Skyler Davenport Drum Circle Hippie Guest Star Jason Elinoff Visitor Guest Star Derrick Gilbert Young Boy Guest Star Abriella Gonzales Child Guest Star Eric Hack Miracle Townsperson Guest Star Fred Keel Italian Restaurant Patron Guest Star Chris Lemchi Church Member Guest Star Bailey Vaughn McAndrew Visitor, High School Student, Encampment Guest Star Caitlyn Moore Hotel Guest Guest Star Robert Lloyd Moore Visitor Guest Star Stacey Morris Jarden Resident Guest Star Artie Mozzone Tourist Guest Star Diane Mozzone Visitor Guest Star Blessing Obot Visitor Guest Star Sabbath Obot Visitor Guest Star Sandy Romero Cave Woman Guest Star Tiana Stuart Telemarketer Guest Star Marilyn Swick Neighbor Guest Star Stan Taylor Visitor Guest Star Gary Teague Italian Restaurant Patron Guest Star Brian Towns Hippie Biker Guest Star Juliet Washington Townsperson Guest Star Alex West Darius Guest Star Pamela A. Yarborough Visitor Guest Star Robert T. Yarborough Visitor Guest Star Sydney G. Yarborough Visitor Guest Star Damon Lindelof Executive Producer, Writer Tom Perrotta Executive Producer Peter Berg Executive Producer Sarah Aubrey Executive Producer Mimi Leder Director Jacqueline Hoyt Writer