Alexandra Chando Emma Becker, Sutton Mercer Actor Andy Buckley Ted Mercer Actor Allie Gonino Laurel Mercer Actor Alice Greczyn Madeline "Mads" Rybak Actor Blair Redford Ethan Whitehorse Actor Charisma Carpenter Rebecca Sewell Rybak Actor Helen Slater Kristin Mercer Actor Adrian Pasdar Alec Rybak Actor Christian Alexander Thayer Rybak Actor Tyler Christopher Dan Whitehorse Actor Ryan Rottman Jordan Lyle Guest Star Sandy Avila Presenter Guest Star Kathryn Smith-McGlynn Dr. Eileen Sandy Guest Star Josh Meyer Carl Guest Star Kasey Stevens Alyssa Guest Star Colby Butterfield Man at Bus Station Guest Star Isabel Elena Arroyo High School Student Guest Star Sandy Romero Country Club Member Guest Star Charles Pratt Jr. Executive Producer Leslie Morgenstein Executive Producer Gina Girolamo Executive Producer John Scott Director R. Lee Fleming Jr. Writer