Rebecca Perry Cutter Creator Brittany Snow Sophie O'Neil Actor Malin Akerman Margo Banks Actor Dermot Mulroney Jed Banks Actor Jaime Ray Newman Callie Actor Katie Lowes Jill Actor Chrissy Metz Starr Actor Evan Jonigkeit Graham O'Neil Actor George Ferrier Brad Actor Chosen Jacobs Jamie Actor Branton Box Sheriff Jonny Actor Jason Davis Reverend Clint Actor Hunter Emery Flynn Actor Karen Rodriguez Salazar Actor Abigail Rhyne Nina Actor Paul Teal Pastor Pete Actor Jill Jane Clements Memaw Actor Scott N. Stevens Mel Osborn Actor Nicole SamuelWashington Joyce Actor Madison Wolfe Abby Actor Nick Hagelin Deputy Chet Ledoux Actor Emmett Moss Jack O'Neil Actor Jeremy Beim Producer, Executive Producer Erwin Stoff Executive Producer Melanie Mayron Director