Jack Burditt Creator, Executive Producer Tim Allen Scott Calvin Actor Elizabeth Mitchell Carol Actor Elizabeth Allen-Dick Sandra Actor Devin Bright Noel Actor Austin Kane Cal Actor Matilda Lawler Betty Actor Kal Penn Simon Choksi Actor Rupali Redd Grace Actor David Krumholtz Bernard the Elf Actor Laura San Giacomo La Befana Actor Jason Winer Executive Producer Jon Radler Executive Producer Kevin Hench Executive Producer Rick Messina Executive Producer Emalee Burditt Writer Hayley Frazier Writer Katie Locke O'Brien Director