Samuel A. Peeples Creator, Writer Barry Sullivan Pat Garrett Actor Clu Gulager Billy the Kid Actor Jim Davis Bob Orringer Guest Star Robert Middleton Paul Mason Guest Star George Macready Judge Roy A. Barlow Guest Star Richard Bakalyan Tiger Eye Guest Star Eduardo Ciannelli Padre Guest Star Judy Nugent June McBean Guest Star Ralph Votrian Johnny Nagel Guest Star King Donovan Mason Henchman Guest Star Mary Webster Marian Swift Guest Star Ken Lynch Andy Gorman Guest Star Olive Sturgess May McBean Guest Star Leonard Nimoy Deputy Sheriff Johnny Swift Guest Star Marianna Hill Rita Guest Star Andy Clyde Pa McBean Guest Star Tom London Prospector Guest Star Joe De Santis Waco Guest Star Linda Dangcil Rosita Guest Star K.L. Smith Guest Star Franklin Adreon Director Frank Arrigo Director Richard Irving Director R. G. Springsteen Director William Witney Director Herschel Daugherty Director Barry Shipman Writer, Screenwriter Tom Seller Writer Henry S. Kesler Director Richard Bartlett Director Lesley Selander Director Frank Price Writer D.C. Fontana Writer, Writer Peter Barry Writer Martin Berkeley Screenwriter Mark Weingart Writer