John Lithgow Larry Henderson Actor Nicholas D'Agosto Josh Segal Actor Jayma Mays Carol Anne Keane Actor Sherri Shepherd Anne Flatch Actor Steven Boyer Dwayne Actor Krysta Rodriguez Summer Henderson Actor Andie MacDowell Margaret Henderson Guest Star Bob Gunton Jeremiah Davis Guest Star Patricia Belcher Judge Horsedich Guest Star Cristine Rose Josie Davis Guest Star Angel Parker Heidi Baker Guest Star Julie Hagerty Madame Rhonda Guest Star Adam Shapiro Harawitz Guest Star Dave Allen Dave the Taxidermist Guest Star Lorna Scott Suzie , Juror 3 Guest Star John Hartman Mitchell Guest Star Loretta Shenosky Edna the Stenographer Guest Star Charles Emmett Juror 2 Guest Star Clint Culp Bailiff Guest Star Barry Livingston Juror 1 Guest Star Seth Coltan Aaron Wilk Guest Star Jeff Astrof Executive Producer Matt Miller Executive Producer Jeffrey Blitz Executive Producer