Poppy Montgomery Carrie Wells Actor Dylan Walsh Det. Al Burns Actor Michael Gaston Det. Mike Costello Actor Kevin Rankin Det. Roe Saunders Actor Daya Vaidya Det. Nina Inara Actor Jane Curtin Joanne Webster Actor Britt Lower Tanya Sitkowsky Guest Star Matt Servitto Dan Marston Guest Star Tracy Sallows Karen Guest Star Elias Koteas Sam Rhodes Guest Star Justin Adams Young Sam Guest Star J. Tucker Smith David Guest Star Bea Miller Katrina Sadler Guest Star Tina Benko Lois Guest Star Steven Anderson Will Hartley Guest Star Bob Angelini Lawyer Guest Star Scott Barrow Worker Guest Star Karl Bury Detective Franks Guest Star Nicolina Capitanio Becky Hartley Guest Star Danielle DeSantis Cheerleader Guest Star Olivia Flynn Young Carrie Guest Star Haley Murphy Rachel Guest Star Ed Redlich Executive Producer, Writer John Bellucci Executive Producer, Writer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer John David Coles Director