Penn Badgley Joe, Will Actor Victoria Pedretti Love Quinn Actor James Scully Forty Quinn Actor Jenna Ortega Ellie Alves Actor Ambyr Childers Candace Actor Carmela Zumbado Delilah Alves Actor Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sera Gamble Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Leslie Morgenstein Executive Producer Gina Girolamo Executive Producer Marcos Siega Executive Producer