Penn Badgley Joe, Will Actor Victoria Pedretti Love Quinn Actor Saffron Burrows Dottie Quinn Actor Tati Gabrielle Marienne Actor Dylan Arnold Theo Actor Shalita Grant Sherry Actor Travis Van Winkle Cary Actor Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sera Gamble Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Leslie Morgenstein Executive Producer Gina Girolamo Executive Producer Marcos Siega Executive Producer Michael Foley Executive Producer David Madden Executive Producer Justin Lo Executive Producer Neil Reynolds Executive Producer Silver Tree Executive Producer