1911

Audience Reviews

View More

Korra N @RT88131552 Nov 11, 2024 What could've been Jackie Chan's greatest performance and film, 1911 is a jarring and hastily-edited mess that feels incomplete. See more

Steve C @RT19610513 Jul 25, 2024 China needs another revolution to take down the corrupt See See Pee, like it did to the corrupt Qing Dynasty. See more

Carl J @RT37151421 Jun 18, 2023 Revolutionary Struggles and Nation Building: 1911 (Xin hai ge ming) Movie Review One of the notable aspects of 1911 is its portrayal of the historical events and the key figures involved. The film provides insights into the political climate and the struggles faced by the revolutionaries during that period. The use of modern warfare tactics and the determination of the characters, particularly Huang Xing and Sun Yat-sen, are highlighted effectively. The film's production values and cinematography are commendable, capturing the essence of the time period and the scale of the revolution. The battle sequences are well choreographed, adding intensity and excitement to the narrative. The attention to detail in the costumes and set designs also adds authenticity to the overall visual presentation. However, despite its historical significance and strong performances by the cast, 1911 falls short in certain areas. The pacing of the film tends to be uneven, with moments of intense action followed by slower narrative segments. This can sometimes disrupt the flow of the story and make it feel disjointed. Additionally, the character development in 1911 is somewhat lacking. While Huang Xing and Sun Yat-sen are portrayed as central figures, their motivations and inner conflicts could have been explored in greater depth. The supporting characters, although important to the historical events, are not given enough screen time to fully develop their arcs. Furthermore, the film's narrative structure can be confusing at times, making it challenging to fully grasp the historical context and the significance of certain events. A more streamlined and cohesive storytelling approach could have enhanced the overall viewing experience. In conclusion, 1911 (Xin hai ge ming) offers a glimpse into an important period in Chinese history and the struggle for independence. While it boasts impressive production values and notable performances, the film's uneven pacing, limited character development, and occasional narrative confusion prevent it from reaching its full potential. Therefore, I would give it a rating of 6 out of 10. See more

Oct 9, 2019 Often disconnected and slow. The scenes with the Empress play comically and ruin the tone, and the film's propaganda is too obvious. See more

Jul 7, 2018 7/7/18 with Zhangs. Good historical review of the demise of the Qing Dynasty See more

Dec 10, 2017 A decent historical account of the revolution in China in 1911. The action was quite good, as was the understanding of one's war outside our own culture and country that we may not have much knowledge on prior to viewing. The subtitles were hard to follow, though, as many were very long and the audience is not given nearly enough time to read them before they vanish from the screen. See more

Read all reviews

1911

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING