Mary Poppins Returns
Log in with Facebook
Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Sign up here
and the Terms and Policies,
and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango.
Already have an account? Log in here
Please enter your email address and we will email you a new password.
Tomatometer Not Available...
No consensus yet.
All Critics (2)
| Top Critics (2)
| Fresh (2)
| Rotten (0)
exquisite, light-drenched tone poem
As poet of heartbreak, Shinkai could be accused of treacly mush (the voice-overs are a bit florid, and the saccharine piano score doesn't help), but he's got a delicate touch with sentiment that will have receptive viewers reaching for a Kleenex.
Is it beautifully animated? Yes. Is it one of the greatest anime movies of all time? Absolutely not. The animators do deserve applause for the gorgeous backdrops and attention to detail. The realistic portrayal of modern settings and aesthetics contributes to the down-to-Earth vibe that the film is going for.
The animation deserves the praise but the quality of the narrative doesn't justify this films almost 'Citizen Kane'-level of critical praise. The story is split up into three episodes in which it follows two young people named Takaki and Akari as they try to preserve their romantic relationship despite long distances. Despite it's broad themes of separation, time, and moving on with life; the plot is rather cookie-cutter. The story never separates itself from a typical one-note angst teen-romance film.
The straightforward plot would not be too much of a problem if it weren't for the one-dimensional characters and the film's pretentiousness. Takaki comes off as a constantly depressed emo, and Akari is never defined outside of being smart. The closest the film gets to a fully developed character is Kanae, and that is only because she loves to surf but even then it's hard to relate to her due to her obsessive behavior towards Takaki.
Another looming issue with the film is that it is pretentious. The word "pretentious" tends to be over-used but here it's appropriate. Even down to the title (which is just a random line that was said in the beginning that provides as a superficial metaphor for time) this film seems to think it is being more profound than what it really is. Dialogue is delivered in strange broken fragments and the music is the typical melancholy piano loops that would not feel out of place in an average indie romance flick.
From an animation standpoint this film is fantastic but great animation can only take a film so far. The under-whelming romance story hinders this film from greatness. It puzzles me why critics and fans alike love this movie so much. It is not particularly deep nor though provoking, it is just an okay straightforward romantic melodrama.
while it's a gorgeous looking piece of work, the story was too corny for me. at just over an hour i'd still recommend checking it out if you're an anime fan
The best animated movie that I have ever seen. Breathtaking scenery over-all makes this film a must-watch. This movie is not only remarkably animated; it's also outstandingly written. It's a poem in motion to be exact, but its harsh reality really hits you in the end, but then again, reality is reality. Its take on love is simple. There are no eyesore plot twist. It's really a simple story with lovable characters and a eye-opener ending. It's only an hour long, but in that short span of time, you'll feel a surge of emotion as it slowly leads you toward the awaited end.
The feelings, thoughts, atmosphere, etc that was created in this animation made this awesome. I liked the colorful scenes that was applied. But to tell you the truth, the back and fourth of the memories made me confused. I was like what-the-hell-is-happening as I saw this in dubbed version. It was indeed realistic. It was about life that you can't get everything no matter how perfectly they match with your life (about life partner, I disagree with this concept and I've my own reasons). And as it left me confused throughout the movie, I felt painfully boring when watching this. Not like I haven't watched dubbed before but maybe because it was so-about-reality, I didn't enjoy this much (I'm very imaginative person).
View All Quotes