Ben Hickernell Director Sarah Megan Thomas Abigail Brooks Actor, Screenwriter, Producer, Executive Producer James Van Der Beek Geoff Actor Glenn Morshower Coach Spriklin Actor Margaret Colin Mrs. Brooks Actor David Alan Basche Cox Actor Alexandra Metz Hannah Actor Meredith Apfelbaum Susan Actor Alysia Reiner Meghan Actor Wynn Everett Reba Actor Ellis Walding Preston Actor Liz Holtan Beth Actor Marceline Hugot Mrs. Atkinson Actor Alexa Salame Vanessa Actor Harlan Bosmajian Cinematographer Phillip J. Bartell Film Editing David Torn Original Music A.R. Brook Lynn Production Design Alanna Dempewolff-Barrett Art Director Mike Locke Set Decoration Sarah Beers Costume Design Stephanie Holbrook Casting