Jeff Garlin Max Morris Director, Actor, Screenwriter Gina Gershon Sophie Actor Nia Vardalos Ava Morris Actor Jami Gertz Rosie Actor Fred Willard Marty Actor Richard Kind Harold Actor Kerri Kenney Caitlin Actor Bob Odenkirk Coach Jimbo Actor Timothy Olyphant Max's Dad Actor J.B. Smoove Coach Ted Actor Max Wright Jack Morris Actor Mindy Rickles Shelley Actor Dave Sheridan Forrest Actor Steve Agee Hezekiah Actor Hope Dworaczyk Angela Actor Peter Murrieta Screenwriter, Executive Producer Erin O'Malley Producer Christine Vachon Producer John Sloss Executive Producer Jonathan Sehring Executive Producer Arianna C. Bocco Executive Producer James Laxton Cinematographer Jonathan Corn Film Editing Nena Hsu Erb Film Editing Larry Goldings Original Music Katie Byron Production Design Alexi Gomez Art Director Rachael Ferrara Set Decoration Christina Mongini Costume Design Marla Garlin Casting