Arthur Penn Director, Producer Penn Jillette Self, Screenwriter Teller Self, Screenwriter Caitlin Clarke Carlotta, Officer McNamara Actor David Patrick Kelly The Fan Actor Leonardo Cimino Ernesto Actor Christopher Durang Jesus Freak Actor Alan North Old Cop Actor Jon Cryer 3rd Frat Boy Actor Jan Weincke Cinematographer Jeffrey Wolf Film Editing Paul Chihara Original Music John Arnone Production Design Beth Kushnick Set Decoration Rita Ryack Costume Design Fran Kumin Casting Meg Simon Casting