Mary Poppins Returns
Log in with Facebook
Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Sign up here
and the Terms and Policies,
and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and Fandango.
Already have an account? Log in here
Please enter your email address and we will email you a new password.
No consensus yet.
Tomatometer Not Available...
No consensus yet.
All Critics (7)
| Fresh (6)
| Rotten (1)
| DVD (2)
The film reveals the penchant of South Korea filmmakers to mix every genre imaginable into one film. This one blends goofy comedy, war drama, tragedy, action and social commentary for a highly entertaining ride.
Korea's answer to Shangri-la is well worth a visit.
This does risk becoming a badly-dubbed episode of 'Allo 'Allo! - but after you get past the sitcom premise, you'll find an engaging and witty little war parody.
Engaging and beautiful cinema.
...offers some valuable insight into Korean culture.
An antiwar film dedicated to South and North Korean reconciliation.
During the Korean war, three surviving members of a PKA unit, two South Korean deserters and an injured American pilot all find themselves in a remote village where the inhabitants lead an idyllic life and know nothing of the outside world. Welcome to Dongmakgol is the kind of pleasant surprise that fuels my love of world cinema. It's a very different approach to the genre of the war film and as such feels really fresh and engaging. It shares similar themes to many other films, most notably Witness in that it's a story of people of violence learning a simpler, more rewarding way of life, The Thin Red Line in the way it contrasts the lives of "uncivilized" people bemused by the hatred people who are otherwise complete strangers breed for each other without really knowing the real reasons why and even Seven Samurai in the finale when the violence of the outside world threatens to shatter the villager's peaceful existence. The village "crazy girl" even has a touch of the Amelies about her. It does have its flaws; the style can sometimes get in the way of the substance in that the soundtrack is rather overly intrusive and it is over-directed in places (the "boar hunt" scene is so absurdly over the top I'm not sure whether it's meant to be taken seriously or not). This means it can get a little overly melodramatic, but otherwise Welcome To Dongmakgol is a very sweet natured, Capra-esque tale that gets under your skin in the nicest possible way.
This is a damn good film that really has no story at all. There is a 'narrative' per se, but it's mostly seeing how these soldiers, when faced with a village that is completely ignorant to war and to pretty much everything that is happening in the outside world, develop a strong bond with each other and the people of this village. There's also a certain surreal aspect to the film, because everything in the village is so far removed from what's actually happening that you're never sure of what's going on here and why, in a time of war and violence, did this village manage to survive all that. The story eventually becomes a "war" film with the soldiers fighting the enemy in order to protect this village they've all grown to love. And, surprisingly, the drama in this film actually works because the film clearly cares about its characters. They're all, with the exception of Second Lieutenant Pyo, not particularly complex characters but they are characters that you care about. They're all very endearing to be honest. The film also has its fair share of comedy. I particularly enjoyed the bit with Pyo and Lee having their first serious conversation while both have a case of diarrhea. It sounds ridiculous and absurd, but it absolutely works. Unfortunately, even if it's well-intended, the war stuff at the end is the weakest part of the film. They are doing it for a reason, but it just felt strange and slightly out of place. And I say slightly, because the film was still, partly, a war film. That's about it really, this is a heartfelt and touching comedy with plenty of social commentary to boot.
Equal parts of dark humor, sadness and inspiring moments combine in this story of a North Korean, South Korean and American unit meeting in a remote village during the Korean war, so out of touch they not only don't know about the war, but what guns are, etc. Putting aside their differences to help the villagers, they soon find commonalities between them. A nice anti-war/humanizing statement. A great cast interspersed with a touching script and excellent direction make this another wonderful example of Korean film making.
I haven't been this uplifted by a film since seeing Amelie for the first time. I was expecting something good but not this amazing. I've heard it described as a live action Studio Ghibli film and I think that captures the essence of this classic best. It is not only a fantastical journey of a film, but one with stunning visuals and expertly crafted scenes. The funny moments are absolutely hilarious and it mixes dark comedy with a much sweeter variety effortlessly. The scene with the boar is pure excitement and the sad scenes are tear jerking. Never failing to shift the mood with some consistency the film has a fantastic array of characters each played to perfection. Only the American cast let the film down as their acting styles seemed so forced. The political morals do not swamp the film and it is quite simply a delightful piece.
There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.