David Walton Will Freeman Actor Minnie Driver Fiona Actor Benjamin Stockham Marcus Actor Al Madrigal Andy Actor Annie Mumolo Laurie Actor Adrianne Palicki Dr. Samantha Lake Guest Star Keith Powell Richard Guest Star Jacob Hopkins Eddie Guest Star Rob Reiner Bagel Shop Owner Guest Star Ava Davila Madison Guest Star Aaron Fernando Alex Guest Star Ethan Herisse Jordan Guest Star James Sklena Cal Guest Star Jason Katims Executive Producer Jon Favreau Executive Producer Tim Bevan Executive Producer Eric Fellner Executive Producer Liza Chasin Executive Producer Robert De Niro Executive Producer Jane Rosenthal Executive Producer