Sarah Thorp Creator, Writer Billy Crystal Eli Actor, Executive Producer Jacobi Jupe Noah Actor Ava Lalezarzadeh Cleo Actor Hope Davis Dr. Jane Guest Star David Niu Restaurant Owner Guest Star Maria Dizzia Barbara Guest Star Rosie Perez Denise Guest Star Emma Fagerstrom Little Girl Noah Guest Star Judith Light Lynn Guest Star Will Fitz Student Guest Star Rebecca Ruane Sophie Guest Star Julia Chan Therapist Guest Star Liam Garten Classmate Guest Star Miriam Shor Sue Ann Guest Star Barbara Bain Ruth Guest Star Holden Goodman Bar Patron Guest Star Sakina Jaffrey Gail Guest Star Will Hochman Benjamin Walker Guest Star Jet Wilkinson Executive Producer, Director Adam Bernstein Executive Producer, Director David Petrarca Director Howie Miller Writer Joseph Sousa Writer Barry Levinson Executive Producer, Director Audrey Rosenberg Writer Eric Roth Executive Producer, Writer Zetna Fuentes Director Desta Tedros Reff Writer Emmanuel Osei Kuffour Jr. Director Emmy Grinwis Writer