Pete Wentz Host Joe Capobianco Judge Sabina Kelley Judge Hannah Aitchison Judge Alayna Magnan Contestant Amy Zager Contestant Anthony Zamora Contestant Carey Matthews Contestant Danny Lepore Contestant Darnell Waine Contestant Izzi Echo Contestant Joseph Matisa Contestant Karly Cleary Contestant May May Yaeger Contestant Romeo Lacoste Contestant Rudy Hetzer Contestant Willy Cutlip Contestant Lara Slater Contestant Kimberly Caldwell Host Jonathan Murray Executive Producer Gil Goldschein Executive Producer Rick de Oliveira Executive Producer