Andy Samberg Detective Jake Peralta Actor Andre Braugher Captain Ray Holt Actor Terry Crews Sergeant Terry Jeffords Actor Melissa Fumero Detective Amy Santiago Actor Joe Lo Truglio Detective Charles Boyle Actor Stephanie Beatriz Detective Rosa Diaz Actor Chelsea Peretti Gina Linetti Actor Dirk Blocker Detective Michael Hitchcock Actor Jenny Slate Bianca Guest Star Ray Campbell Special Agent Marx Guest Star Joe Sabatino Benny Guest Star Sari Lennick Bev Guest Star Derick Alexander Airport Official Guest Star Joel McKinnon Miller Norman Scully Actor Amato D'Apolito Mafia Thug #1 Guest Star Nick DeMauro Tony Guest Star Paul Mabon Officer Lou Guest Star Daniel J. Goor Executive Producer Mike Schur Executive Producer David Miner Executive Producer Dean Holland Director Luke Del Tredici Writer