Joel McHale Host, Executive Producer Curtis Stone Judge Yolanda Gampp Judge Bob DeLuca Contestant Vikki DeLuca Contestant Amber Croom Contestant Yassmeen Haskins Contestant Laissa Forlini Contestant Camille Marion Contestant Enrique "Ricky" Saucedo Contestant David "DJ" Thomas Contestant Christina Mathis Contestant Jenae Cartwright Contestant Sherry Mach Contestant Sally Mach Contestant Torre Liebchen Contestant Michelle Micek Contestant Steph Hsu Contestant Sin Yi Cherry Lau Contestant Donovan Peters Contestant Dayveon Shawver Contestant Kathleen Regelman Contestant Hannah Reyes Contestant T Lawrence-Simon Contestant Fadi Odeh Contestant Kristy Gardner Contestant Tarsha Joyner Contestant Conrad Green Executive Producer Allison Grodner Executive Producer Rich Meehan Executive Producer Ashley S. Gorman Director