Bradley James Damien Thorn Actor Megalyn Echikunwoke Simone Baptiste Actor Omid Abtahi Amani Golkar Actor Barbara Hershey Ann Rutledge Actor David Meunier Detective James Shay Actor Scott Wilson John Lyons Guest Star Michelle Krusiec Fumika Eiko Guest Star Bola Aiyeola Mrs. Baptiste Guest Star Fode Bangoura Babalawo Guest Star Brody Bover Jacob Shay Guest Star Daniel Kash Captain McGarry Guest Star Larry Mannell Mr. Panic Guest Star Melanie Scrofano Veronica Selvaggio Guest Star Michael Therriault Patrick Guest Star Juan-Carlos Velis Father Frank Esparza Guest Star Ross Fineman Executive Producer Nazrin Choudhury Writer Bronwen Hughes Director