Jon Robin Baitz Creator Joe Baken Creator Ryan Murphy Creator, Executive Producer Joshua Jackson Max Actor Don Johnson Captain Robert Massey Actor Phillipa Soo Avery Morgan Actor Sean Teale Tristan Silva Actor Kelli Berglund Penny Hollister Actor Cameron Deane Stewart Gabe Hollister Actor Chelsea Zhang Shea Butter Lady Actor Whitney Cummings Mona Yeager Actor Paris Barclay Executive Producer Jamie Pachino Writer Russel Friend Writer Our Lady J Director