Tom Cavanagh Ed Stevens Actor Julie Bowen Carol Vessey Actor Jana Marie Hupp Nancy Burton Actor Josh Randall Dr. Mike Burton Actor Lesley Boone Molly Hudson Actor Michael Ian Black Phil Stubbs Actor Rachel Cronin Shirley Pifgo Actor Daryl "Chill" Mitchell Eli Goggins Actor Justin Long Warren Cheswick Actor Sabrina Lloyd Guest Star Chris Isaak Guest Star Steven R. Schirripa Guest Star Rob Burnett Executive Producer Jon Beckerman Executive Producer David Letterman Executive Producer