Jemaine Clement Jemaine Actor, Writer Bret McKenzie Bret Actor, Writer Rhys Darby Murray Hewitt Actor Kristen Schaal Mel Actor Arj Barker Dave Actor Eugene Mirman Eugene Actor Luther Creek Mickey Guest Star Lenny Venito John Guest Star Kelly Taffe Police Officer Guest Star Diana Bologna John's Date Guest Star Marilyn Torres Jemaine's Date Guest Star Richard Wilkinson Reuben Guest Star James Bobin Writer, Director Troy Miller Executive Producer Stu Smiley Executive Producer Tracey Baird Executive Producer