Breckin Meyer Jared Franklin Actor Mark-Paul Gosselaar Peter Bash Actor Malcolm McDowell Stanton Infeld Actor Dana Davis Carmen Phillips Actor Kumail Nanjiani Pindar Singh Actor Reed Diamond Damien Karp Actor Garcelle Beauvais-Nilon Hanna Linden Actor Natalie Zea Isabella Kaplowitz Guest Star Fred Willard Wallace Clayton Guest Star Alexandra Holden Debbie Wilcox Guest Star Tom Wilson Spiritual Advisor Guest Star Julian Acosta Henry Stein Guest Star Leslie Murphy Annabelle Guest Star Freda Foh Shen Judge Leslie Hong Guest Star Leslie Thurston Jury Foreperson Guest Star Jamie Tarses Executive Producer Jason Ensler Executive Producer, Director Kevin Falls Executive Producer Bill Chais Executive Producer Jeff Rake Writer