Jennifer Love Hewitt Melinda Gordon Actor David Conrad Jim Clancy Actor Camryn Manheim Delia Banks Actor Jay Mohr Prof. Rick Payne Actor Brooke Grant Guest Star Courtnee Draper Guest Star Autumn Reeser Guest Star Camille Chen Guest Star Max Hoffman Guest Star Robert Garrova Guest Star Cassius M. Willis Guest Star Mae Whitman Guest Star Afemo Omilami Guest Star Kris Lemche Guest Star Stephanie Erb Guest Star Kevin Kilner Guest Star Katy Boyer Guest Star Rob Elk Guest Star John Gray Executive Producer Ian Sander Executive Producer, Director Kim Moses Executive Producer Laurie McCarthy Writer Teddy Tenenbaum Writer