Adam Scott Max Jennifer Actor, Executive Producer Craig Robinson Leroy Wright Actor, Executive Producer Ally Walker Captain Ava Lafrey Actor Adeel Akhtar Dr. Barry Shaw Actor Amber Stevens West Annie Actor Britt Lower Claire Jennifer Guest Star Megalyn Echikunwoke Natalie Guest Star Lauren Lindsey Donzis Shannon Lafrey Guest Star Seth Morris Keith Jorgensen Guest Star Jeff Witzke Pete (Host) Guest Star Tom Gormican Executive Producer Kevin Etten Executive Producer Naomi Scott Executive Producer Oliver Obst Executive Producer Mark Schulman Executive Producer Jonathan Krisel Executive Producer