Oscar Morgan Turner Hayes Actor Olivia Rose Keegan Duela Actor Fallon Smythe Harper Row Actor Tyler DiChiara Cullen Row Actor Misha Collins Harvey Dent Actor Anna Lore Stephanie Brown Actor Navia Ziraili Robinson Carrie Kelley Actor Rahart Adams Brody Actor Chad Fiveash Executive Producer James Stoteraux Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Natalie Abrams Co-Executive Producer Leigh London Redman Executive Producer Brooke Pohl Writer Amy Do Thurlow Writer Ben Hernandez Bray Director