Daniel Sunjata Paul Briggs Actor Aaron Tveit Mike Warren Actor Vanessa Ferlito Catherine "Charlie" DeMarco Actor Brandon Jay McLaren Dale "DJ" Jakes Actor Manny Montana Joe "Johnny" Tuturro Actor Serinda Swan Paige Arkin Actor Carmine Giovinazzo Sid Markham Guest Star John Kapelos Lawrence Guest Star Jamie Gray Hyder Lucia Guest Star Coby Ryan McLaughlin Archie Guest Star Mercedes Colon Mrs. Tuturro Guest Star Jon Sklaroff Fritz Guest Star Matt Mercurio Kyle Guest Star Jeff Eastin Executive Producer Sanford Bookstaver Director Carla Ching Writer