Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Steve Tefft Actor Anthony Michaels Actor DJ Tambe Actor Roly T-Rex Contestant Garrett Bisbee Contestant Katie Rhoden Contestant Gary Parisi Contestant Fame Montalvo Contestant Jeremy Brown Contestant Josh Payne Contestant Chris Sparks Contestant Matt Buck Contestant Lil D Contestant Frank Ready Contestant Deanna Smith Contestant Juan Salgado Contestant Linzy Ink Contestant Mike Diaz Contestant Amanda Leitch Contestant Daniel Silva Contestant Jason Elliott Contestant Tim Furlow Contestant Thare "Tee" Maequez Contestant Rachel Helmich Contestant Rachael Head Contestant Koko Contestant Christian Masot Contestant Andrea Richter Executive Producer Steven Weinstock Executive Producer Glenda Hersh Executive Producer